Skip to main content

A mystery solved ?– vagrancy in Siberian Phylloscopus warblers

        

Over wintering Yellow-Browed Warbler, Frampton on Severn, January 2025

One of the avian phenomena that perplexes me most is the yearly UK autumn arrival of significant numbers of Siberian Phylloscopus warblers. Every year I travel to see Yellow-Browed Warblers that are overwintering in the UK and wonder what on earth they are doing here.  This is a really perplexing one as these delightful little leaf warblers breed in the eastern palearctic and migrate to tropical and south-east Asia for the winter. So overwintering birds in the UK have flown some 5,000 km in the wrong direction in perhaps the largest UK example of reverse migration. One  intriguing possibility is that mother nature is using reverse migration to establish independent breeding colonies hence mitigating the risk of the species being wiped out by some environmental  catastrophe in their home breeding range.

 

I’ve ponder this perplexing question many times in my blogs, see here. I’ve also previously reviewed the excellent “Vagrancy in Birds” by Alexander Lees and James Gilroy which discusses the possible cause of vagrancy in a wide range of avian species.

 

A recent excellent scientific paper, “Using age-ratios to investigate the status of two Siberian Phylloscopus species in Europe” seems to have solved this conundrum. The authors studied records of overwintering Yellow-browed Warblers  and Siberian Chiffchaffs caught and ringed in western Europe. 

 

Quoting the paper

 

“Because migratory songbirds tend to follow the same orientation and migration route throughout their lives, age assessment can help to distinguish individuals which have already used a route (i.e. adults) from those using it for the first time (i.e. juveniles). The presence of a significant proportion of adult individuals would suggest the presence of regular migrants in a vagrancy context.”

 

They looked at 324 records of Yellow-browed Warblers caught at various locations over the past decade and found that only one was a definitive adult indicating that a new migration route is not being established. As migration route fidelity is very strong, this sadly suggests that none of these bird survive to migrate as adults.

 

The findings with Siberian Chiffchaffs were markedly different. Of the 117 records investigated 30% of overwintering birds were adults. Again assuming migration route fidelity, this  indicates that these birds have established a sustainable alternative winter migration route. Giving the difficulty of establishing pure breed Sibs from interbreeds DNA analysis was used to  establish their genetic purity. A pure Sib was defined as one having a hybrid score of 5% or less. They found 36 pure sibs with a score >95% and 19 individuals with a score <95%  suggesting these later birds have a history of some past hybridisation with Common Chiffchaffs. This raises the strong  possibility that new migration routes are being created by the presence of some Common Chiffchaff genes in the Sib population.

 

I hope I have summarise this excellent piece of scientific research correctly but If you find this interesting, I strongly suggest you read the original paper which has much more detail on the authors study and conclusions.


Footnote – my blogs are posted with sometimes rather imaginative spelling and grammar due to my extreme dyslexia!  

 

 

 

 

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Albert the Albatross

  What is more improbable -   a)     England’ football team    beating Germany in the knockout stages of a major competition   b)     Seeing an Albatross in England   Actually the answer is a) because it has not happened since 1966 rather than b) as Albert the Albatross, as he is affectionally known, has made a number of passing visits to the UK since 1967!   On Monday evening reports started to emerge of Albert associating with the Gannet colony at RSPB Bempton Cliffs in Yorkshire, almost one year after his    last brief visit to the same site. During the intervening period there have been a number of sightings of Albert across Europe, particularly from the Baltic Sea where he appears to have spent much of the last 12 months. In fact there were reports that he had been attacked and killed in the area by two eagles.    Reports of his death were clearly greatly exaggerated!   The Black-browed Albatross is ci...
2 comments
Read more

The Hawfinches of the Forest of Dean

   Hawfinch - Forest of Dean, winter 2017 A highlight of my winter birding is my annual trip to the Forest of Dean to see Hawfinches. I was unable to go last year due to the post-Christmas lockdown so this year’s visit was even more richly anticipated than normal.   Parkend in the Forest of Dean is my usual chosen location for watching Hawfinches. Here the proven technique of using your car as a hide normally works well. I must also say that,  after a number of quite strenuous twitches recently, I was also looking forward to a much more leisurely birding session!   The story of Hawfinches in the UK is, to my mind at least, a fascinating one. It is what is known as an eruptive species meaning that it occasionally erupts from its traditional breeding grounds to invade on mass countries much further away. This is thought to be driven by a combination of breeding success and local crop failure resulting in not enough food to go around.    Records indi...
3 comments
Read more

A visit to see a controversial Canvasback and thoughts on its provenance

   Canvasback ( its the one with the long black beak) curtsey of Nick Truby   Ornamental ducks are perhaps the most difficult and controversial birds that are on the current  British bird list. They are widely kept in collections and as such differentiating a genuine wild vagrant from an escapee is extremely challenging and sometimes impossible. I’ve discussed the issue of proving a birds provenance before, see here , but in summary a ring or isotopic analysis of a sample are required to prove beyond all doubt that the bird is a genuine vagrant. In the absence of this objective evidence of origin much more subjective factors are used to prove that the bird is “probably” a genuine wild bird. You could, however,  strongly argue that in the absence of the definitive evidence above, none of these ornamental ducks should be on the UK list of accepted wild birds   The Canvasback is the North American cousin of our common Pochard and is kept in some UK o...
1 comment
Read more